As Amazon Associates, we earn from qualifying purchases. This means we may receive a small commission at no extra cost to you if you click through and make a purchase.
As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases. Links on this page are affiliate links.
Finding the best WaterRower rowing machines under $2000 requires looking closely at build quality and dimensions. We compared 2 models using only the specifications published on their official listings. The WaterRower Walnut S4 Handcrafted Rower takes the top spot because it offers a solid 61.7-pound frame in a compact 84-inch width. This specific weight and footprint make it ideal for buyers wanting a premium walnut rower. These picks focus on material and size data to help you decide which model fits your home space.
Compare weight and storage space
You should check the weight and dimensions before buying. The top pick weighs 61.7 pounds. The runner-up weighs 63.9 pounds. Both measure 84 inches long. This length is fixed for both models. You need adequate floor space. Choose based on how much weight you prefer to move for vertical storage.
| # | Product | Best for | Price |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | WaterRower Walnut S4 Handcrafted Rower Best overall | Buyers wanting a premium walnut rower | |
| 2 | WaterRower Ash Rowing Machine Also great | Users seeking traditional ash wood construction |
The best fit for you
- You want a premium walnut handcrafted rower – WaterRower Walnut S4 Handcrafted Rower – It features a durable walnut finish and weighs 61.7 pounds.
- You prefer traditional ash wood construction – WaterRower Ash Rowing Machine – It uses durable ash wood and offers smooth water resistance.
- You need a rower with vertical storage – WaterRower Walnut S4 Handcrafted Rower – Its 22-inch height allows for upright vertical storage.
WaterRower Walnut S4 Handcrafted Rower
Best for: Buyers wanting a premium walnut rower
- Resistance Type
- Water
- Display Type
- S4 BLE Monitor
- Frame Material
- Walnut wood
- Storage Design
- Store on end
- Dimensions
- 21 × 84 × 22 inches
- Weight
- 61.7 pounds
This WaterRower Walnut model uses a water-filled flywheel for smooth, self-regulating resistance. It features the S4 BLE Monitor to track your workout data. The frame is handcrafted from sustainably sourced Appalachian walnut wood. It measures 82 inches long and weighs 103.5 pounds with water. You can store it vertically on end to save space. This machine suits those who want a durable, USA-made rower with a natural aesthetic.
- Handcrafted walnut wood frame sourced from Appalachian forests
- S4 BLE Monitor for tracking workout metrics
- Water flywheel provides smooth, natural resistance
- Vertical storage design saves floor space
- Heavier build at 103.5 pounds with water added
- Longer footprint at 82 inches in length
- Single wood finish option of walnut
- You value handcrafted American-made construction
- You prefer the natural feel of water resistance
- You need a machine that stores vertically
- You require a compact footprint under 80 inches
- You prefer a lighter machine for frequent moving
- You want multiple wood finish choices
Verdict: WaterRower Walnut S4 Rowing Machine is a solid choice for buyers seeking a durable, USA-made rower with a premium walnut finish. It fits those who prioritize handcrafted quality and vertical storage over a smaller footprint.
WaterRower Ash Rowing Machine
Best for: Users seeking traditional ash wood construction
- Resistance Type
- Water
- Display Type
- S4 Monitor
- Frame Material
- Ash wood
- Storage Design
- Store on end
- Dimensions
- 21 × 84 × 22 inches
- Weight
- 63.9 pounds
The WaterRower Ash Rowing Machine features a handcrafted ash wood frame and a water-filled flywheel for natural resistance. It includes the S4 Monitor for tracking performance metrics. The unit measures 84 inches long and weighs 63.9 pounds. You can store it vertically on end to save floor space. This model suits those seeking a durable, USA-made rower with a traditional aesthetic.
- Handcrafted ash wood frame built in the USA
- Water resistance provides smooth, self-regulating effort
- Includes S4 Monitor for workout data
- Vertical storage design saves space
- Longer footprint at 84 inches in length
- Heavier build at 63.9 pounds compared to lighter alternatives
- You want a handcrafted wooden rower made in the USA
- You prefer natural water resistance over magnetic or air systems
- You have space for an 84-inch long machine
- You need a compact rower under 70 inches long
- You prefer a lighter machine under 50 pounds
- You want digital connectivity like Bluetooth monitoring
Verdict: WaterRower Ash Rowing Machine fits buyers who value traditional craftsmanship and durable ash wood construction. It is ideal for those with adequate floor space who prefer the smooth feel of water resistance.
Specifications side by side
| Spec | WaterRower Walnut S4 Handcrafted Rower | WaterRower Ash Rowing Machine |
|---|---|---|
| Resistance Type | Water | Water |
| Display Type | S4 BLE Monitor | S4 Monitor |
| Frame Material | Walnut wood | Ash wood |
| Storage Design | Store on end | Store on end |
| Dimensions | 21 × 84 × 22 inches | 21 × 84 × 22 inches |
| Weight | 61.7 pounds | 63.9 pounds |
| Color | Walnut | Lo-Rise |
| Model | Walnut S4 | 100 |
How to choose the right WaterRower
Check the wood type
You should decide between walnut and ash based on your aesthetic preference. The top pick features a premium walnut finish for a high-end look. The runner-up uses traditional ash wood construction. Both materials are durable and suitable for home use. Choose walnut if you want a darker, richer tone. Select ash for a lighter, classic appearance. The wood type does not change the water resistance performance. It only affects the visual style of the machine in your home gym.
Measure your floor space
You must ensure you have enough room for the rower's length. Both models measure 84 inches long when in use. This is a fixed dimension that cannot be adjusted. You need clear space in front of the machine for the slide. Check your room dimensions before purchasing. If you have limited space, consider the vertical storage option. The height is 22 inches, which allows for upright storage. Verify your ceiling height and floor area to fit the 84-inch length.
Consider the weight capacity
You should look at the machine weight to understand its stability. The top pick weighs 61.7 pounds. The runner-up weighs 63.9 pounds. This weight helps keep the machine steady during intense rows. Heavier machines generally offer more stability for larger users. Check the manufacturer's weight capacity limit for your body weight. Ensure the floor can support the static weight. The weight also affects how easy it is to move. Heavier units may require two people to lift and reposition.
Verify vertical storage needs
You need to check if the machine fits your storage constraints. Both models have a height of 22 inches. This allows them to stand vertically in a corner. You can store them upright to save floor space. Measure your storage area height to ensure it fits. The 22-inch height is compact for storage. You do not need to disassemble the rower to store it. This feature is useful for small apartments or garages. Confirm your storage space can accommodate the 22-inch vertical profile.
Understand water resistance
You should know that both machines use water resistance. This type of resistance scales with your rowing speed. Faster pulls create more drag, providing a natural feel. The water tank size determines the maximum resistance. Both models offer smooth, quiet operation. You do not need to adjust settings for different intensity levels. The resistance is self-regulating based on your effort. This makes it easy to control workout intensity. You only need to fill the tank to the marked line.
Frequently asked questions
Which WaterRower model is best for those wanting a premium walnut finish?
The WaterRower Walnut S4 Handcrafted Rower is the top choice for buyers seeking a premium walnut rower. It features a durable, USA-made build with a high-end walnut finish. This model weighs 61.7 pounds and measures 84 inches in length. It fits users who prioritize handcrafted quality and vertical storage options over a smaller footprint.
What is the best WaterRower for traditional ash wood construction?
The WaterRower Ash Rowing Machine is ideal for users seeking traditional ash wood construction. It offers durable ash wood build quality with smooth water resistance. This model weighs 63.9 pounds and measures 84 inches long. It is perfect for those with adequate floor space who value traditional craftsmanship and the natural feel of ash wood.
How do the dimensions of these WaterRower models compare?
Both the Walnut S4 and Ash models share identical length and height dimensions. Each measures 84 inches in length and 22 inches in height. The width for both is 21 inches. You need adequate floor space for this fixed length. The height allows for vertical storage, making them suitable for homes with limited room for large equipment.
What is the weight difference between the top two WaterRower picks?
The top pick, the Walnut S4, weighs 61.7 pounds. The runner-up, the Ash model, weighs 63.9 pounds. This is a difference of 2.2 pounds. Both machines are substantial, so you should check your floor capacity. The weight contributes to stability during intense rowing sessions, ensuring a solid feel with each stroke.
Do these WaterRower machines use water resistance?
Yes, both the WaterRower Walnut S4 and the Ash Rowing Machine use water resistance. This type of resistance provides a smooth, natural rowing feel. The resistance level adjusts based on how hard you pull, mimicking real rowing on water. This mechanism is consistent across both models, ensuring a similar workout experience regardless of your wood choice.
Can I store these WaterRower machines vertically?
Yes, both models are designed for vertical storage. Their 22-inch height allows them to stand upright on their end. This feature saves significant floor space when the rower is not in use. You simply need to ensure you have enough clearance above the machine when it is stored in this vertical position.
Which WaterRower is better for small spaces?
Neither model is particularly compact, as both are 84 inches long. However, both allow for vertical storage due to their 22-inch height. This reduces the footprint when not in use. If space is tight, consider how much floor area you can dedicate to the 84-inch length during workouts. The Walnut S4 is slightly lighter at 61.7 pounds.